Gateway on Fourth is planned for the 1400 block of East Fourth Street on Bethlehem's South Side. It's planned in two phases with 120 homes in all, and the first phase pairs a 44-unit mid-rise with a 16-unit townhome building. Every one of those homes will be a rental, Lehigh Valley Public Media reported. That holds for almost everything going up across the city. Bethlehem is building plenty of housing, but very little of it can be bought.
That changes how a buyer should read the city. In the suburbs, new construction gives you a choice between a builder's model and someone's existing house. Inside Bethlehem, the new buildings mostly add to the rental market. If you want to own here, you're buying a home that already exists, and that resale market has its own numbers.
Fourth and Third Streets, South Side
Pennrose is developing Gateway on Fourth with the City and LVIP, and more than two-thirds of its homes are priced as affordable. The first phase is aimed at households earning 20 to 60 percent of area median income, with reported rents from $279 for a one-bedroom to $1,442 for a three-bedroom, according to Lehigh Valley Public Media. As of June, Pennrose expected to close financing by the end of 2026 and start construction in early 2027, LehighValleyLive reported.
Two blocks west, Marshall Valley opened in August 2025 in the 100 block of East Fourth Street. It has about 75 apartments over ground-floor commercial space, per The Morning Call's list of Bethlehem projects to watch in 2026.
On the Third Street side, The Gatehouse from J.G. Petrucci and Peron Development is next to the Polk Street garage. It's a five-story building with 44 apartments and 5,600 square feet of street-level retail, and in March Lehigh Valley Business reported it was expected to finish in the spring. Nearby, Bethlehem planners approved a seven-story building at 404 E. Third St. with 80 apartments over commercial space and residential parking in the Polk Street Garage, WFMZ reported. Planners also approved a smaller plan at 330 E. Fourth St. for four two-bedroom apartments over commercial space.
Add up these South Side projects and you get a few hundred apartments and no for-sale homes at all.
Broad Street, Downtown and the North Side
Across the river, Broad Street follows the same pattern at a larger size. DLP's Dream Boyd Theatre apartments, on the old Boyd Theatre site, are finished and open to tenants. The building has 205 rental units, and about 30 percent were occupied when WFMZ toured the building this year.
A few blocks west, planners approved a seven-story conversion and addition at 46–52 W. Broad St., the former Wells Fargo building, with 61 apartments over ground-floor retail. WFMZ reported that county records show an LLC registered to Monocacy Builders bought the property for $1.6 million.
Downtown is getting the same thing as the South Side: more apartments over storefronts. If you've been comparing Bethlehem with nearby areas and liked the walkable center described in our piece on everyday life around historic downtown Bethlehem, keep in mind that most of the new housing there is being built for renters.
Eighth Avenue and the Northeast
At the former Martin Tower site, the two Lehigh Valley Health Network medical office buildings there, 100,000 square feet in total, opened in July 2025. The site's approved plan also includes about 1,085 apartments. In May 2025, Lehigh Valley Public Media reported that city officials were still waiting on unit plans from the developer. Those units are planned as apartments too.
Pembroke, in northeast Bethlehem, is the clearest place where ownership is in the plans. The city's redevelopment plan would replace 196 public-housing units with 456 new ones, mixing market-rate rentals, homes for sale and subsidized units, The Morning Call reported last November. The same article put construction at five to seven years if the city gets implementation funding, or 10 to 15 years under a tax-credit approach. A buyer shopping this winter is looking at a different decade.
Where the For-Sale Homes Come From
Zoning approvals in the city lately have been small infill. At 1224 Eaton Ave., zoners advanced a scaled-back plan from PAJ Venture LP for five homes: three attached townhomes and two semi-detached houses, per WFMZ. Projects at that size don't change the market.
The whole region is building the same way. Lehigh Valley Planning Commission figures cited by Lehigh Valley Public Media count 5,891 proposed housing units across the Lehigh Valley in 2025. Of those, 3,450 were apartments, 988 detached houses, 952 rowhouses, 387 twins and 78 condos. Those are proposals, and not all of them get approved. Still, condos were barely more than 1 percent of what developers pitched, and that's the category a city buyer would most expect to see new.
The apartments are meeting real demand. A report covered by Lehigh Valley Business in October ranked the Lehigh Valley the third-most competitive small rental market in the country. Occupancy was above 95 percent, 14 renters competed for each vacancy, and the region added no rental stock from April through June. Bethlehem's construction is aimed at that problem. For a buyer, a new 205-unit building on Broad Street adds 205 places to rent and no listings.
So if you want to own in Bethlehem, you're shopping the rowhomes, twins and single-family houses already standing. Our comparison of a townhome or single-family home in Bethlehem covers how those choices differ.
What the Resale Numbers Say Through September
Greater Lehigh Valley REALTORS reports Bethlehem by school district, so the figures below cover the Bethlehem Area School District market area, not the city alone. In GLVR's September 2026 market report, the district had 785 closed sales from January through September 2026, exactly the same as the same nine months of 2025. New listings in that period rose 3.6 percent to 1,020, while pending sales slipped 0.5 percent to 828. Active inventory at the end of September was 130 homes, up 6.6 percent from 122 a year earlier.
Bethlehem's existing housing stock is selling at the same pace as last year. More owners listed, buyers went under contract at about the same rate, and the extra listings showed up as a slightly bigger supply on the market at the end of September.
Price moved more. The district's average sale price for January through September 2026 was $386,158, up 6.1 percent from $364,019 in the same period of 2025. Across Lehigh and Northampton counties combined, the year-to-date average was $417,945, up 5.2 percent. Bethlehem homes still sold below the two-county average, but prices climbed faster.
The two-county September snapshot shows how deals went that month. The median sale price was $375,000, up 6.8 percent from September 2025, and homes went under contract in an average of 20 days. Sellers received 100.8 percent of their most recent list price, and supply stood at 1.8 months. These are regional figures, and the median is a different measure from the averages above, but they describe the market the Bethlehem numbers sit in. In September, a buyer offering at or above asking still had room to negotiate on terms, and not much room on price.
Reading Bethlehem Against Its Neighbors
The same GLVR table puts Bethlehem's average between its two closest comparisons. For January through September 2026, the Allentown School District averaged $275,846 on 620 sales, and the Easton Area School District averaged $418,564 on 526 sales. Easton's sales fell 11.1 percent and Allentown's fell 5.2 percent over that stretch, while Bethlehem's stayed flat.
Put that next to the construction list. The city with the most new apartments on its main streets also held its sales volume steady at prices rising faster than the region's, all on existing homes. New rentals on Fourth Street and Broad Street aren't adding to what buyers compete for, so a buyer shouldn't wait for them to ease prices. What could change Bethlehem's for-sale supply is more owners deciding to list, and through September, a few more did.
A Few Questions Buyers Ask
Are any of the new South Side buildings condos? No. Gateway on Fourth, Marshall Valley, The Gatehouse and the approved 404 E. Third St. building are all rentals.
Will the Martin Tower site add homes for sale? The approved residential plan there is about 1,085 apartments, not for-sale homes.
Are the Bethlehem numbers city-only? No. GLVR reports the Bethlehem Area School District market area, not the city alone.
Whether you're comparing Bethlehem with other Lehigh Valley towns or own a home in one of the city's older neighborhoods, the market here is made up of houses that already exist. If you own one and want to see where it sits in that market, Daniel Witt Real Estate Group is here to help. Get your free home valuation, or visit our Bethlehem neighborhood page and buyer's guide if you're shopping for one.